|
Published
January 2008
No Shortcuts
By Doug Day (page 26)
Advanced Wastewater Engineering specializes
in sound solutions for challenging sites in the varied soils of
the Idaho panhandle.
Challenging jobs are an everyday reality
for George Miles, owner of Advanced Waste-water Engineering in
Athol, Idaho.
“I deal with difficult sites,” says Miles,
a mechanical engineering graduate of San Francisco State
University and a licensed civil engineer. “We go in and figure
out ways to make them buildable by adding things such as
interceptor drains to mitigate groundwater. These are lots
people gave up on years ago.”
Miles doesn’t take shortcuts just to get a
system installed. “Normally, my customers come to me because
they want to do the right thing,” he says. Sitting on the
western side of the Rocky Mountains, Idaho’s northern panhandle
has a huge variety of soil conditions, from pure sand and gravel
all the way to clay and rock. The valleys have high groundwater
with heavily fractured rock.
Around Athol, the sand and gravel soil
lies over the sole source of drinking water for the region’s
450,000 people. According to the State Dept. of Environmental
Quality, water moves quickly through the ground — up to 50 feet
per day. That’s as far as average ground-water moves in an
entire year (about 1.5 inches a day).
“You put effluent into the ground and it’s
going to run right through,” Miles says. “Every septic system
over this aquifer should be as close to the surface as possible
with whatever loamy soil you have so you get some filtration.”
After many years in California, Miles had
been doing structural engineering in North Idaho when he decided
to open his own business three years ago. He quickly found a
niche that fit his years of training: There were no companies
specializing in onsite systems in his part of Idaho. “Customers
had to go to one of the big firms, and then they were put on the
back burner as a fill-in job,” Miles says.
Deploying technology
Today’s advanced systems enable Miles to
make many lots buildable. He does everything from standard
systems to drip irrigation, mounds, capping fill, pretreatment,
and pressure distribution. “The drip system is ideal for areas
of high groundwater,” he says. “You pretreat the effluent and
then put it into a drip system.”
Advanced Wastewater Engin-eering also does
heavy work related to construction — road work, excavation and
grading, underground utilities, water and sewer extensions, and
site evaluation. Many clients are subdivision developers. Miles
determines how many houses can be placed in a development and
whether to use individual or cluster systems. Such projects
account for about half his work. Single sites make up the rest.
He and one employee, plus his
secretary/wife, Cathy, do one to three community systems a year,
usually ranging from 12 to 25 homes. “We’re just finishing a
16-home community septic system in Kingston that took four men 3
1/2 weeks to build,” he says.
The company is also working on a
development with 30 lots that will have individual or paired
systems with two homes on one leachfield. He just received
approval for a community system for 14 homes along the St. Joe
River.
The seven to 12 individual systems he does
every year are mainly complex designs with pressure distribution
and pretreatment. Miles says almost anyone can design a system
in Idaho unless it is specifically required to be engineered.
The state is not as strict as many others, but Miles says it is
becoming more so, especially with drip systems.
He has had problems with only one of his
drip systems. In that case, Miles found the flow from the
three-bedroom home was 600 to 700 gpd — nearly twice the design
flow. He couldn’t account for the high flow until he learned the
homeowner had installed a water softener that was flushing two
or three times a day. Once the softener was disconnected, the
flow settled down to about 400 gpd, and the homeowner decided to
leave it that way.
Miles’ most challenging job was a winery
in California that used a huge amount of water for washing out
wine barrels. “It needed 4,000 to 5,000 linear feet for the
primary drainage area, and we had to work around the vineyard,”
he says.
Old West mentality
Idaho values independence, but Miles says
that attitude has to change when it comes to onsite systems, and
the state realizes that. He recently served on a state committee
looking at solutions. Miles expects change to be difficult —
people will not like anything that adds to the cost of building
or owning a home.
While other states have done away with
systems using serial relief lines, for instance, Miles says they
are still used in Idaho. “When I bring that up, everybody says
we’ve been doing it for 20 years and it works fine. People don’t
want to hear why they shouldn’t do it. But you don’t have the
right to impact somebody downhill.”
While the state’s Technical Guidance
Manual lays out the design parameters, that isn’t enough,
according to Miles. “If you actually try to use that, it won’t
work right,” he says. That’s because every system is different,
and successful operation only comes from the proper installation
of a well-designed system. “So a lot of people come to me and
say, ‘fix what’s broken.’”
One of those was a friend putting in a
drainfield with 1/4-inch holes spaced 2 feet on center along
three 100-foot laterals hooked up to one manifold. The friend
wanted to know what size pump he needed. “I told him he’d need a
bigger pump than he wanted to buy,” Miles says. “We ended up
re-engineering the system.”
There is an inherent problem with what he
calls plug-and-play design programs because every system has
individual nuances. “You have to take into account all the
friction loss and whether you’re using PVC pipe or high density
polyethylene (HDPE) pipe. A lot of people don’t know how to do
that calculation.”
Even if the design is right, the key is
still in the installation. With mounds, for example, “You have
to avoid packing down the sand, so you can’t drive on it with
equipment,” Miles says. “On the other hand, when you put down
the sand, it’s fluffy, so you have to wet it to help it settle
properly.”
While inspecting a mound system from
another installer, he saw what happens when a professional fails
to do that. “When we did the test of the laterals, I watched the
gravel bed start sinking,” he says. “It sank down about 2 1/2
inches. It was the funniest thing I’d ever seen in my life.”
The installer was confused and asked why
it happened. Miles answered the question with one of his own:
“Because you didn’t build it right?”
Bad systems are the result of poor design,
poor installation, and poor regulation, Miles observes. “You
look at what people do and it’s like, ‘You don’t understand
this, do you? You really don’t get this concept.’”
Regulation: Not a bad thing
Miles supports stricter licensing for
onsite installers. At present, getting a license is too easy, he
says. “You have to watch a video before taking the test,” he
notes. “There should be a more practical way to get these
licenses.” He supports mandatory classes that show good and bad
examples, and a requirement for continuing education.
Lending institutions, he says, are having
a positive impact by requiring septic tanks to be pumped and
inspected before the sale of a property. That at least forces
homeowners to learn something about their septic systems.
As in the rest of the country, uneducated
consumers are a problem. An example is a neighbor who called
Miles one night because his system was backing up. Miles dug up
the tank and pulled off the lid. “It looked like somebody had
taken a refrigerator, piled the food up, put a tarp over it, and
let it sit for six months,” he recalls. “All this broken- down
food was floating on the top of the tank.”
Miles had a hunch that proved correct: His
neighbor had cleaned the refrigerator and put everything through
the garbage disposal. That won’t happen anymore.
Do it right
While he concentrates on difficult sites,
Miles has his focus on operating a professional organization. He
hires several sub-contractors, but he is picky about who he
uses. His go-to man is Sean Moore of Moore Electrical &
Excavation. “We can do an entire drip system, just the two of
us, in three days,” Miles says.
From Moore, he gets what he demands: high
quality and professionalism. “When you leave a site, it should
be clean,” he says. “If it looks like a mess, it is a mess.
Referral work is where most of the business comes from, and if
your clients aren’t happy with the work, you aren’t going to be
referred, no matter how cheap you do it, even if you’re the only
guy in town. If you do a shoddy job, sooner or later somebody’s
going to come in and take your work away.”
Miles’ first three years have gone well.
“I have a lot of happy clients, though a couple of people are
unhappy because I can’t get a septic system on their lot,” he
says. While he could rig a system to please those customers,
Miles wouldn’t be happy with the results, or with himself.
By refusing shortcuts, Miles is steadily
building a bank of satisfied customers — and a solid foundation
for his business.
|